Ranking the Most Controversial Talismans in Elden Ring: From Disappointing to Essential

Tarnished, welcome to another deep dive into the vast and occasionally confusing variety of Amulets in Elden Ring. In this article, we'll take a deep dive into some of the more controversial and perplexing Amulets introduced in recent DLC. From puzzling design choices to surprising practicality, let's break down which Amulets deserve your attention and which you can safely ignore. Also, Looking to enhance your Elden Ring experience and maximize your potential in the Lands Between? MMOexp is your go-to destination for acquiring Elden Ring Runes with ease. Whether you're looking to level up, upgrade your gear, or fine-tune your builds, MMOexp offers a reliable and efficient service to help you gather the Runes you need quickly. Skip the grind and focus on what truly matters—exploring the vast world of Elden Ring, battling fearsome foes, and uncovering hidden secrets. With MMOexp, you're not just buying Runes; you're investing in a smoother, more enjoyable gameplay experience.

Number 39: Talisman of Lords

The Talisman of Lords provides a modest boost to poise, which is supposed to help you push through large attacks without being interrupted. However, the 54% increase is negligible unless your poise is already at a very high level. If you’re relying on this talisman to make a significant difference, you might be disappointed. The utility of damage reduction during healing animations would have been a more effective approach. If your poise isn't already in the upper echelon, this talisman probably isn't worth your time.

Number 38: Beloved Stardust

Beloved Stardust aims to enhance casting speed but comes with a 30% reduction in damage negation. The dexterity cut-off at level 70 means it’s not particularly useful for most builds, especially if you’re not focused on high dexterity. The trade-off between faster casting and reduced damage negation is rarely beneficial, making this talisman a bit of a disappointment unless you’re specifically building around casting speed.

Number 37: Vertigo's Discus

The Vertigo's Discus attempts to offer damage reduction based on your weight class but misses the mark with its implementation. The lack of medium load damage reduction and the requirement to be overloaded to get the full benefit make this talisman impractical for most players. The need to drag your character around with heavy loads just to get a decent damage reduction is a design flaw that makes this talisman frustrating rather than useful.

Number 36: Model Necklace +2

The Model Necklace +2 increases resistance to a single ailment but doesn’t offer much beyond that. With more efficient ways to deal with ailments already available, this talisman feels like a half-hearted attempt to balance status effects. If you’re building around a specific status ailment, you might find this useful, but otherwise, it doesn’t offer much in terms of utility.

Number 35: Ailment Talisman

The Ailment Talisman is another addition that seems to be a reaction to community feedback. While it can be useful in certain builds, especially for Madness builds, it doesn’t offer much beyond situational utility. If you’re keen on maximizing your Madness build's potential, this talisman could be of interest, but for most players, it’s more of a niche pick.

Number 34: Cerulean Seed +1

The Cerulean Seed +1 boosts FP restoration from the Cerulean Flask, but its utility is limited. Given that the Cerulean Flask already restores a significant amount of FP at higher levels, this talisman’s benefit is marginal. Unless you’re running extremely low on FP or prefer a specialized FP regeneration build, this talisman doesn’t offer much advantage.

Number 33: Talisman of All Crucibles

This talisman provides a notable increase in damage output across the board while trading off reduced damage against critical hits. The fact that it consolidates the Crucible talismans into one slot makes it a strong choice for maximizing damage, but the reduction in critical hit damage might be a deal-breaker for some. It’s a solid pick if you’re looking for a one-slot solution to multiple Crucible effects.

Number 32: Outer God Heirloom

The Outer God Heirloom is locked behind significant progress in the base game, which can feel frustrating. It’s primarily useful for meeting Arcane requirements and potentially boosting certain builds, but its high entry barrier makes it less accessible. If you’re focused on specific Arcane builds, it could be valuable, but it’s not essential for most players.

Number 31-29: Plus Two Horn Charms

The Plus Two Horn Charms, which offer increased status resistance, are overshadowed by the more effective Exaltation talismans. The incremental increase in resistance isn’t enough to make these a standout choice compared to the more comprehensive benefits of the Exaltation tree. They’re a marginal improvement at best and generally not worth prioritizing.

Number 28: Retaliatory Crossed Tree

The Retaliatory Crossed Tree boosts damage from rolling and backstepping attacks but is limited in its application. Given that these attacks have fixed damage multipliers and you can only perform light attacks post-dodge, this talisman’s effectiveness is limited. If your playstyle heavily relies on rolling attacks, it might be worth considering, but for most players, it’s not a game-changer.

Number 27: St. Trina’s Smile

St. Trina’s Smile, aimed at boosting the Sleep status, feels awkward due to its limited practical application. With only a few ways to trigger Sleep and a lack of effective bosses to exploit this status, it’s not a standout choice. It’s more of a niche item with limited use, and better options are available for most builds.

Number 26-24: Plus Three Medallions

The Plus Three Medallions provide marginal improvements in spell casting and health restoration. While useful in theory, the practical benefits are minimal compared to other available options. They offer slight boosts in FP restoration or health, but most players will find other talismans more effective.

Number 23: Fine Crucible Feather

The Fine Crucible Feather offers unique niche benefits but is generally overshadowed by other talismans. Its utility with backstep attacks is limited, and the increased damage taken makes it a risky choice. It’s worth experimenting with if you’re keen on specific playstyles but isn’t a must-have for most players.

Number 22: Sharpshot Talisman

The Sharpshot Talisman provides a boost to precision mode attacks and works well with certain weapon skills. If you’re focused on precision-based builds and want to maximize your arrow damage, this talisman can be useful. However, its niche application means it might not be necessary for every build.

Conclusion

Not every Amulet is created equal in Elden Ring, and some can be downright frustrating to use. While some of these amulets offer unique benefits or cater to specific play styles, others fall short in terms of practicality. Whether you’re looking to fine-tune your loadout or simply explore new options, understanding the pros and cons of each amulet can help you make smarter choices and enhance your Elden Ring experience. Unlock the full potential of your Elden Ring adventure without breaking the bank by visiting MMOexp for cheap Elden Ring Items. Our platform offers a wide range of affordable gear, weapons, and consumables designed to elevate your gameplay and enhance your journey through the Lands Between. With MMOexp, you can access the items you need at prices that won’t strain your resources, allowing you to focus on exploring, battling, and conquering without worrying about overspending. Embrace a more cost-effective way to gear up and get ahead in Elden Ring—trust MMOexp for all your in-game item needs.